Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Home / Case Digests / Appellate Division, Fourth Dept. / Civil Servant: Emmerling v. Town of Richmond

Civil Servant: Emmerling v. Town of Richmond

Appellate Division, Fourth Department

Civil Servant

Misconduct — Termination

Emmerling v. Town of Richmond
TP 11-00294
Appealed from the Supreme Court, Ontario County

Background: The petitioner commenced an Article 78 proceeding seeking to annul the determination to terminate his employment as a recreational specialist for the respondent. The petitioner argued that the determination was not supported by substantial evidence and the penalty of termination was an abuse of discretion.

Ruling: The Appellate Division held that the determination was supported by substantial evidence. The petitioner’s duties included extensive contact with children and he had been notified that he was required to act as a role model for them. The petitioner, by selling alcohol to a minor, had committed misconduct in violation of the Penal Law. In light of the circumstances, termination was not disproportionate of a penalty for such misconduct.


Christina A. Agola for the petitioner; Edward C. Kenyon of the Kenyon & Kenyon Law Firm for the respondent