Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Tag Archives: jury verdict

US appeals court tosses out $654 million verdict against PLO

NEW YORK — A U.S. appeals court on Wednesday tossed out a $654 million jury verdict against the Palestine Liberation Organization for terrorist attacks in the early 2000s in Israel that killed or wounded Americans, saying the U.S. courts lack ...

Read More »

New York State Court of Appeals – Jury Verdict: People v. DeLee

New York State Court of Appeals – Jury Verdict – Inconsistency – Repugnancy   People v. DeLee No. 189 Judge Read   Background: A grand jury indicted the defendant for second-degree murder as a hate crime, second-degree murder and third-degree criminal ...

Read More »

New York State Court of Appeals – Jury Verdict: Motelson v. Ford Motor Company

New York State Court of Appeals – Jury Verdict – Emotional Distress Damages – Failure to Argue at Trial   Motelson v. Ford Motor Company No. 195 Memorandum   Background: At issue is whether the plaintiffs suffered, or would continue to ...

Read More »

Fourth Department — Jury Verdict: Carnevale v. Elizabeth Wende Breast Care LLC

Appellate Division, Fourth Department  Jury Verdict Juror’s Affidavit — Bias Carnevale v. Elizabeth Wende Breast Care LLC CA 12-01638 Appealed from Supreme Court, Wayne County Background: The plaintiff commenced a medical malpractice action alleging that the defendant failed to make ...

Read More »

Fourth Department — Jury Verdict: Applebee v. County of Cayuga

Appellate Division, Fourth Department Jury Verdict Inconsistent Interrogatory Responses — County Clerk’s Authority Applebee v. County of Cayuga CA 11-02090 Appealed from Supreme Court, Cayuga County Background: The plaintiff commenced an action against the defendant-third-party plaintiff, Cayuga County, when he ...

Read More »

Fourth Department — Jury Verdict: People v. Members

Appellate Division, Fourth Department Jury Verdict Missing Juror People v. Members KA 08-02020 Appealed from Monroe County Court Background: The defendant was convicted by a jury of several felonies, including second-degree murder. On appeal, he contended that County Court improperly ...

Read More »

Fourth Department — Jury Verdict: Herbst v. Marshall

Appellate Division, Fourth Department Jury Verdict Against the Weight of Evidence Herbst v. Marshall CA 11-00326 Appealed from Supreme Court, Niagara County Background: The plaintiff sought to recover damages when the defendant’s vehicle rear-ended the plaintiff’s vehicle. After the completion ...

Read More »

Plaintiff awarded $1.5M in PI case

A unanimous Monroe County Supreme Court jury verdict late last month awarded plaintiff Walter J. Nary $1,571,000 as a result of a 2009 accident on Route 104 in Ontario. Nary was struck from behind while at a stop light at ...

Read More »

Lead poisoning case favors plaintiff

A 23-year-old Rochester woman, left with a learning disability after being exposed to lead as a child, will receive some compensation for her injuries. A jury Wednesday awarded Ashley Hicks $221,000 for economic loss from the neurological effects ...

Read More »